Art & Design

More than 30 years after his death, Andy Warhol is being accused of copyright infringement

Thirty-four years after his death, the "Pope of Pop Art" continues to generate controversy. After initially winning in 2019, the Andy Warhol Foundation just lost the latest verdict in the trial between the foundation and photographer Lynn Goldsmith on Friday, March 26th 2021. The latter is accusing Andy Warhol of having used her portrait of Prince in the 1980s, without authorisation, to produce one of his famous silkscreens.

Le portrait d'Andy Warhol pour Vanity Fair, basé sur la photo de Lynn Goldsmith, Credit: Court Documents

Lynn Goldsmith has finally won her case. After years of legal battles and an initial ruling against her, the American photographer won her case against the Andy Warhol Foundation on Friday March 26th. It all began in 1984, when the American artist, then at the height of his career, produced silkscreens of the famous singer Prince. And while the pope of pop-art is also known for his rich photographic output featuring the faces of many celebrities of the time, on this occasion he didn’t use his own work but a portrait of Prince taken by photographer Lynn Goldsmith in 1981 for the newspaper Newsweek. Although the paper he was supposed to illustrate never saw the light of day, Vanity Fair magazine acquired the rights to one of these photos and asked Andy Warhol to illustrate it, which the artist transformed into a series of 16 portraits. 

 

 

But it took 32 years before the scandal came to a head. In 2016, Vanity Fair republished the series without warning or mentioning the photographer Lynn Goldsmith, who only discovered it when the issue came out. In these portraits based on her photograph, Prince appears alternately blue-faced, red-faced, with yellow hair and a purple moustache. Andy Warhol's touch is unmistakable, but is it enough to declare these portraits as original works by the pop art master? After her discovery, Lynn Goldsmith decided to apply for copyright of the work. The case should have been settled out of court, with the rights recognised and duly paid, but that was before the Andy Warhol Foundation got involved. Established in 1987 following the artist's death, with the aim of defending his legacy but also contemporary creation through the awarding of grants and the organisation of conferences and exhibitions, the foundation rejected the accusation of copyright infringement defended by Lynn Goldsmith: for the Andy Warhol Foundation, there was no doubt that the artist had produced an original work. This was followed by a first lawsuit by the foundation against the photographer in April 2017, resulting in 2019 with an initial verdict in favour of the foundation, against which the photographer appealed.

 

 

It was in the face of this thorny debate that Judge Gerald E. Lynch, who presided over the second trial, ruled last Friday, this time in favour of Lynn Goldsmith. In 2019, the court had considered Andy Warhol's portraits as transformative works: a judgement that has now been reviewed because in the United States, in order to be free of copyright, a work must be truly altered from its original form. In order to justify his verdict, the judge recently explained to Artnet: "In order to fall into the category of transformative use, the new work must offer something more than the simple addition of an artistic style to the primary work. Any secondary work that adds a new aesthetic to the primary source is not necessarily transformative." A decision against which the Andy Warhol Foundation has already announced that it will appeal, no doubt promising a new episode in the case... 

  • How photographer Nadia Lee Cohen shakes up our vision of women

    For six years, Nadia Lee Cohen has photographed dozens of models and built up a rich visual narrative following a unique guide line : the contemporary expression of femininity. These movie-like set up photographs, which have been assembled all together in a book entitled “Woman“, recently published by IDEA, all foil female archetypes through a quirky look, celebrating the diversity of all bodies, ages and gender. For Numéro, the British photographer goes back to her project.

  • Photographer Hiroshi Sugimoto unveils his first coloured works' secrets

    For fifteen years, Japanese major photographer Hiroshi Sugimoto has been exploring a new side to his practice : colour. Inspired by an Isaac Newton's theory, the 73-year-old man uses light to project hues in their purest essence, which on Polaroid films create abstracts landscapes fit for contemplation. For Numéro, the artist comments on his latest series “Opticks”, currently shown by the Marian Goodman Gallery in Paris. 

  • Did Leonardo da Vinci really paint the most expensive work in the world?

    After being sold for $450 million in 2017, and becoming the most expensive work of art in history, the "Salvator Mundi" is now a source of doubt. In a documentary broadcast by France 5 on Tuesday April 13th, the journalist Antoine Vitkine traces the foggy itinerary of this Renaissance portrait, which in fact wasn’t painted by Leonardo da Vinci but by some of his disciples... 

  • Interview with Paola Antonelli, the woman who displays artworks in airports

    Italian-born Paola Antonelli has been a senior curator in the department of architecture and design at the Museum of Modern Art in New York since 1994. Over nearly three decades, she has been on a mission to promote a broad understanding of design, from video games to 3D-printed objects, and led MoMA’s acquisition of the @ symbol, designed by Ray Tomlinson in 1971.

  • Interview with Amoako Boafo, rising star in the art world

    The Ghanaian artist, who is now based in Vienna, paints remarkable portraits of figures from the African diaspora. Among his fans is Kim Jones, who was inspired by Boafo’s work in his most recent Dior Homme spring-summer collection.

  • Controversy: the scandalous art of Philip Guston

    A painter who never ceased experimenting, going from the figurative to the abstract and back again, Philip Guston can be found in all the most prestigious museums around the globe. A major international retrospective of his work is planned for 2024.

  • Andy Warhol and his early homo-erotic drawings

    Famous for his prolific production of paintings and screen prints, Andy Warhol was first and foremost an illustrator who sketched endlessly in his private life while advancing his advertising career. Following the major retrospective at the Tate Modern, Taschen have published a new book featuring more than 300 drawings of men, dating back to the 1950s, and revealing the early flames of the artist’s desire. 

  • “With the cinema, clothes come back to life,” Alessandro Michele and Gus Van Sant unveil a mini-series of films

    The artistic director at Gucci has joined forces with the cult director of “Elephant and “Harvey Milk, to make a miniseries of seven films, presented this week during GucciFest, a digital film and fashion festival. Last Friday, Alessandro Michele and Gus Van Sant spoke via Zoom about the origin of the project, its filming in Rome and their shared love of the movies.

     

  • Trevor Paglen: spy on the live visitors of his new exhibition

    On September 10, Trevor Paglen opened the gates of his new exhibition at the Pace Gallery in London. Once again, the American artist presents works that highlight the dangers of artificial intelligence. He also imagined a creative device inspired by the technological mutations in a post-quarantine era: the virtual visitors can infiltrate the exhibition through multiple cameras and project their own images on the screens. Numéro spoke with the artist about his work.

  • Mega-gallery owner Larry Gagosian as seen by British painter Jenny Saville

    Leader of the Young British Artists in the 90s, Jenny Saville stands out with her striking nude paintings. As part of our summer series on the relationship between artists and gallery owners, the British painter Jenny Saville opens up about her singular relationship with gallery owner Larry Gagosian – founder and leader of the mega-gallery that bears his name – who introduced her to Willem De Kooning's New York.

  • All you need to know about Danh Vo : the groundbreaking artist seen by Mathieu Paris

    White Cube gallery's director Mathieu Paris opens up about his fascination with Danh Vo, able to create a dialogue between Coca-Cola and Jesus Christ. 

  • A rare drawing by Jean-Michel Basquiat is estimated at 10 million dollars

    On Thursday July 2nd, the auction house Philips is organising a sale of works by some of the biggest artists of the 20th century. Among this impressive collection is a drawing by Jean-Michel Basquiat created a year before his death and now worth an estimated 10 million dollars. Part of the proceeds made from its sale will go to The Art of Justice Fund, fighting mass incarceration.